Friday, June 3, 2011

Growing Beyond Growth

Yale Environment 360 today tackles the question of whether our focus on economic growth harms our well-being.  James Gustav Speth wrote:

There are some, myself included, who believe that the U.S. is now experiencing uneconomic growth. If one could measure and add up all the environmental, security, social and psychological costs that U.S. economic growth generates at this point in our history, they would exceed the benefits of further ramping up what is already the highest GDP per capita of any major economy.

Though not widely accepted, the case is strong that growth in the affluent U.S. is now doing more harm than good. Today, the reigning policy orientation holds that the path to greater well-being is to grow and expand the economy. GDP, productivity, profits, the stock market, and consumption must all go up. This growth imperative trumps all else. It can undermine families, jobs, communities, the climate and environment, and a sense of place and continuity because it is confidently asserted and widely believed that growth is worth the price that must be paid for it...

It is time for America to move to post-growth society where the natural environment, working life, our communities and families, and the public sector are no longer sacrificed for the sake of mere GDP growth; where the illusory promises of ever-more growth no longer provide an excuse for neglecting to deal generously with our country’s compelling social needs; and where true citizen democracy is no longer held hostage to the growth imperative.

1 comment:

  1. I think there is a strong argument that EVERY society larger than a local county does more harm than good. Virtually all complex organizational effort creates more Entropy than can be regulated in any kind of timely manner to minimize negative and unforeseen costs.

    Even complexity itself is based on a drive toward a type of simplicity that leads to Chaos, whether mathematical or social. Even if Humanity could somehow, with incredible ingenuity and global creativity, gather all its Entropy and shoot it "harmlessly" into the Sun, the death of the Sun and Earthbound Humanity would indeed be accelerated, maybe unpredictably sooner rather than indefinitely later.

    ReplyDelete